#1 Harvard Doctor: The Most Harmful Foods Causing Brain Disease (EAT THIS)

Summary notes created by Deciphr AI

https://youtu.be/HUvBy0VMLDY?feature=shared
Abstract

Abstract

Dr. Georgia Eid, a Harvard-trained psychiatrist and author of "Change Your Diet, Change Your Mind," emphasizes the profound link between diet and mental health. She argues that many mental health disorders, such as depression, bipolar disorder, and schizophrenia, are brain disorders often exacerbated by poor dietary choices, particularly high carbohydrate intake leading to glucose spikes and inflammation. Eid advocates for a diet rich in animal proteins and fats, suggesting that reducing carbohydrates can stabilize brain chemistry more effectively than medications. She also highlights the potential cognitive risks of statin drugs and the importance of gradual dietary transitions.

Summary Notes

Key Themes

The Role of Diet in Mental Health

  • Mental health disorders are brain disorders, and brain health is significantly influenced by diet.
  • Many people are consuming too many harmful carbohydrates, leading to glucose spikes in the bloodstream and brain.
  • Proper dietary changes can correct chemical imbalances in ways that medications cannot.

"Most people are eating too many of the wrong carbohydrates with every meal and snack. They're getting these dangerous glucose spikes in the bloodstream, therefore also in the brain."

  • Incorrect dietary information has led to widespread suboptimal mental health.

"We actually, because we've been fed the wrong information about nutrition for generations, we have been feeding our brains improperly our entire lives."

  • A brain-healthy diet is crucial for optimal mental function, contrary to the belief that cognitive decline is inevitable with age.

"We expect our brains to function less well over time, we expect our brains to deteriorate over time, and our memory to start to fail us. This is what we've been led to believe is normal, but it is anything but."

Mental Health Issues vs. Mood Disorders

  • Mental health issues encompass a broad range of conditions, including mood disorders, concentration problems, sleep issues, and more.
  • Mood disorders specifically relate to one's outlook on life, such as depression and bipolar disorder.

"All mood disorders are mental health issues, but not all mental health issues are mood disorders."

  • Mental health disorders can manifest in various ways, including anxiety, irritability, mood swings, and memory problems.

"Mental health issues can be anything from concentration problems to sleep problems to energy, sort of difficulty with mental stamina, productivity, could also be anxiety, irritability, mood swings, memory problems."

Prevalence and Impact of Mental Health Disorders

  • Nearly one billion people globally suffer from mental health conditions severe enough to interfere with their ability to function.
  • Many more people likely suffer from undiagnosed mental health issues.

"Nearly one billion people in the world now have mental health conditions so serious that it qualifies under the category of disorder, which means that it's so serious as to interfere with some aspect of the person's ability to function."

  • Functional forms of anxiety and depression can be normal and adaptive, but they should not be disabling.

"Anxiety can be a good thing, but you can have too much of a good thing for no reason. The same thing with depression; it's normal to feel depressed or down if you've gone through a serious loss, but it shouldn't last a long time and it shouldn't paralyze you."

The Connection Between Mental Health and Brain Health

  • Mental health disorders often involve brain damage, including inflammation and deterioration of brain structures.
  • Conditions like major depression, bipolar disorder, and schizophrenia increase the risk of developing dementia.

"Mental health disorders are brain disorders, and they often particularly in more serious conditions such as major depression, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, and of course dementia, the brain itself is experiencing damage."

  • Similar underlying issues such as inflammation, oxidative stress, and insulin resistance are common across various mental health conditions.

"If we look at these serious mental health conditions, they may look very different on the outside, but on the inside, they actually have a lot in common."

The Importance of Correct Dietary Information

  • Many standard dietary recommendations directly promote poor mental health by contributing to inflammation, oxidative stress, and nutrient deficiencies.
  • Correct dietary information can lead to significant improvements in mental health.

"If you have the right information about diet, you can actually turn things around for yourself rather quickly in a lot of cases."

Dr. Georgia Ede's Personal Experience

  • Dr. Ede experienced chronic health issues in her early 40s, including chronic fatigue, fibromyalgia, IBS, and migraines.
  • Conventional medical treatments were ineffective, leading her to experiment with her diet.

"I went to see lots of specialists. They did all kinds of tests and told me that everything was normal, which of course it wasn't. None of them asked me what I eat."

  • Through trial and error, Dr. Ede discovered a diet that reversed her physical and mental health symptoms, which was contrary to standard dietary recommendations.

"I ended up with a diet that was almost completely upside down and backwards from what we're told is good for us, and that was the diet that completely reversed all of the physical health symptoms."

  • This personal experience led her to study nutrition deeply and advocate for dietary changes to improve mental health.

"I fell in love with nutrition science, and what I came to understand is that the diet that is supposed to be so dangerous for me, which was very high in animal protein, animal fat, and cholesterol, was actually very good for the brain."

Quotes and Explanations

"Mental health disorders are brain disorders, and they often, particularly in more serious conditions such as major depression, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, and of course dementia, the brain itself is experiencing damage."

  • This quote emphasizes that mental health disorders involve physical damage to the brain, highlighting the importance of brain health in mental health treatment.

"Most people are eating too many of the wrong carbohydrates with every meal and snack. They're getting these dangerous glucose spikes in the bloodstream, therefore also in the brain."

  • This quote points out the detrimental impact of high carbohydrate intake on brain health, leading to glucose spikes that can affect mental health.

"If you have the right information about diet, you can actually turn things around for yourself rather quickly in a lot of cases."

  • This quote underscores the potential for dietary changes to significantly improve mental health, emphasizing the importance of correct dietary information.

"I ended up with a diet that was almost completely upside down and backwards from what we're told is good for us, and that was the diet that completely reversed all of the physical health symptoms."

  • This quote highlights Dr. Ede's personal experience with a diet that contradicted standard recommendations but led to significant health improvements.

"I fell in love with nutrition science, and what I came to understand is that the diet that is supposed to be so dangerous for me, which was very high in animal protein, animal fat, and cholesterol, was actually very good for the brain."

  • This quote reflects Dr. Ede's journey to understanding the benefits of a diet high in animal products for brain health, challenging conventional dietary advice.

Misconceptions About a Healthy Diet

  • Common beliefs about a healthy diet include the necessity of whole grains, a plant-based focus, and the avoidance of saturated fats.
  • There is no scientific, biological, or logical basis for many of these dietary recommendations.
  • Much of the dietary advice is based on untested theories and wishful thinking rather than solid scientific evidence.

"The information that we have been led to believe about what a healthy diet should look like is almost completely incorrect and there is no science behind the majority of the recommendations."

  • The speaker argues that the true science of food biology and human biology points to a different dietary approach.

"All of these beliefs about nutrition... there's no science behind them whatsoever, there's no logic behind them, there's no biology behind them, there's no rationale."

  • Removing unscientific studies and focusing on the biology of food and the body can lead to clear and logical dietary guidelines.

"If you remove all those so-called nutrition epidemiology studies from your thinking, you create an epidemiology-free zone, you end up with very clear, very logical, very simple rules about what human beings are supposed to eat to support optimal health."

Meat-Centric Diet

  • The diet discussed is centered around animal foods, with flexibility based on individual metabolic tolerance to carbohydrates and plant foods.
  • Not all plant foods are equally nutritious or safe; grains, beans, nuts, and seeds are considered some of the least nutritious and riskiest.

"This is a diet that must include at its core animal foods... what you include beyond that is really up to you, based on your metabolic tolerance."

  • The speaker is not convinced that plant foods are necessary but acknowledges that some people can be healthy with a mix of plant and animal foods.

"I think many of us can be robustly healthy if we include a decent amount of plant food in the diet, but we do need to understand that not all plant foods are created equal."

Dietary Carbohydrates and Glucose

  • Carbohydrates are the only macronutrient that is entirely optional in the human diet.
  • The body can produce glucose through a process called gluconeogenesis, using protein and fat.

"The dietary carbohydrate is completely optional of the three macronutrients... we can make all of our own glucose from protein and fat smoothly, reliably, for the rest of our lives."

  • The speaker argues that generating glucose internally is more stable and potentially healthier than consuming dietary carbohydrates.

"It may be better for you to make your own glucose rather than to get most of your glucose from dietary carbohydrate because when you make your own glucose, it's a demand-driven system."

Community Support for Carnivore Diet

  • The speaker mentions the benefits of a carnivore diet for mental and physical health.
  • A community has been established to support individuals interested in the carnivore diet, offering guidance from certified doctors and coaches.

"I followed a carnivore diet for the last 4 years and I have seen incredible improvements not only in my mental health but also in my physical health."

  • The community provides resources like meal plans, fat loss challenges, and medical advice.

"If you're thinking about starting a carnivore diet, I would love to invite you to join our Go Carnival Community... we have board-certified carnivore and keto doctors to help answer your most common medical questions."

Genetic Influence on Mood Disorders

  • Most mood disorders are influenced by genes but are not determined by them.
  • Twin studies show that the risk of mood disorders is much lower than 100%, indicating that genes are not the sole cause.

"Most conditions that humans face have a genetic component... but they are not by and large caused by our genes."

  • The environment and lifestyle choices have a significant impact on the expression of these genes.

"Your genes are paying attention to what you eat and they're turning on and turning off based on the environment that you are creating for them."

Chemical Imbalances and Neurotransmitters

  • Mood disorders are often attributed to imbalances in neurotransmitters like serotonin, dopamine, and norepinephrine.
  • These imbalances can be caused by diet, particularly the consumption of refined carbohydrates.

"The brain is a beautifully sophisticated organ... even if you only look at neurotransmitter balance, you can find this beautiful connection between how we eat and how our neurotransmitters are produced and how they are balanced or unbalanced."

  • High intake of refined carbohydrates can lead to spikes in blood glucose, which in turn affects brain glucose levels and neurotransmitter balance.

"Every time your blood sugar spikes, your brain sugar also spikes... when you've got too much glucose in the brain, that extra glucose literally sticks to proteins and lipids and DNA molecules."

  • This process creates advanced glycation end products (AGEs), which contribute to premature aging of the brain and other tissues.

"These are called Advanced Glycation End Products... it's well established that AGEs are a main driver of premature aging of the brain and many other tissues throughout the body."

Impact of Inflammation and Oxidative Stress

  • The brain's immune system responds to high glucose levels by releasing inflammatory cytokines and oxygen-free radicals.
  • This response can destabilize neurotransmitters, leading to mood disorders.

"Whenever you get a wave of inflammation or oxidative stress, that is having a profound impact on this regulatory pathway."

  • The imbalance between neurotransmitters like serotonin, dopamine, glutamate, and GABA can lead to symptoms like anxiety, panic, and difficulty concentrating.

"Instead of having just the right amount of serotonin, melatonin, dopamine... you get less serotonin, more dopamine, less GABA, and up to 100 times more glutamate."

  • Chronic consumption of refined carbohydrates can keep the brain in a constant state of emergency, contributing to mental health issues.

"Most people are eating too many of the wrong carbohydrates with every meal and snack... you're getting waves of inflammation and oxidative stress and you are destabilizing multiple neurotransmitters."

Conclusion

  • Understanding the true science behind diet and its impact on mental health can lead to better dietary choices and improved mental well-being.
  • Diet is a foundational aspect of health, influencing neurotransmitter balance and overall brain function.

"If people have the right information about what's causing the chemical imbalances in the first place, you can do a lot more with dietary changes to help yourself stabilize your chemistry from within."

Risks and Limitations of Psychiatric Medications

  • Psychiatric medications can only influence a few neurotransmitters.
  • Effective medications often come with significant side effects.
  • Antipsychotics can lead to insulin resistance, type 2 diabetes, and obesity quickly.

"Even the most effective psychiatric medications, which still don't help most people, can only at best influence maybe two or three of these neurotransmitters."

  • Psychiatric medications have limited efficacy in treating mental health conditions.

"The price you pay for the relief that you may get is often tremendous in terms of the side effects you're going to experience."

  • The side effects of psychiatric medications can be severe and outweigh the benefits.

"These medicines can increase your glucose and insulin levels within minutes to hours of the very first dose."

  • Antipsychotic medications can rapidly lead to metabolic issues.

Food-First Approach to Mental Health

  • Prioritize dietary changes before resorting to medications.
  • Medications should be used for emergencies or when dietary changes are not feasible.
  • Diet can stabilize brain chemistry naturally.

"I think a food first, do no harm policy is the best approach in most cases."

  • Starting with dietary changes can often address mental health issues without the need for medications.

"Why not start by feeding the brain properly first and taking yourself off of this chemical roller coaster?"

  • A proper diet can stabilize brain chemistry more sustainably than medications.

Role of Cholesterol in Brain Health

  • The brain is rich in cholesterol due to its high membrane content.
  • Myelin, essential for nerve signal transmission, is rich in cholesterol.
  • Cholesterol is vital for synapse function and brain cell communication.

"The brain is rich in cholesterol because it is rich in membranes."

  • Cholesterol is essential for the structural integrity of brain cells.

"Myelin is just tightly coiled membranes wrapped around our electrical connections inside of our brain."

  • Myelin, which insulates nerve cells, is cholesterol-rich and crucial for proper brain function.

"Cholesterol plays a very important role in synapse function, in brain cell communication."

  • Cholesterol is critical for effective communication between brain cells.

Impact of Statins on Brain Health

  • Statins can cross the blood-brain barrier and interfere with cholesterol production in the brain.
  • Many patients experience cognitive impairments when starting statins.
  • Statins increase the risk of type 2 diabetes, which is harmful to cardiovascular health.

"All of them cross the blood-brain barrier, all of them interfere with cholesterol production in the brain."

  • Statins disrupt the brain's ability to produce necessary cholesterol.

"They start to have problems with their memory, thinking clearly, and word finding."

  • Cognitive impairments are common side effects of statin use.

"Statin drugs increase your risk for type 2 diabetes."

  • The increased risk of type 2 diabetes from statins is well-documented and harmful to overall health.

Patient Empowerment and Decision-Making

  • Patients should view themselves as active participants in their healthcare.
  • Physicians are advisors, and the final decision rests with the patient.
  • Patients should educate themselves and weigh the risks and benefits of treatments.

"We are all advisers; you get to make the final decision."

  • Patients have the autonomy to make informed decisions about their treatments.

"Listen to all of us, do your own homework, and you decide."

  • Patients should gather information from multiple sources before making healthcare decisions.

Importance of Fat for Brain Health

  • The brain is rich in fat, including saturated fat.
  • Fat is essential for cell membranes and brain cell signaling.
  • Omega-3 fatty acids are crucial for visual processing, mitochondrial function, and the immune system.

"The brain is very rich in fat as well, and it's not just canola oil up there; quite a bit of it is actually saturated fat."

  • Saturated fat is a significant component of brain structure.

"Fat is not just a structural component of all cells but also serves very important functions in brain cell signaling and development."

  • Fat plays multiple roles in maintaining brain health beyond just structural integrity.

Insulin and Fat Storage

  • Insulin regulates fat storage and burning.
  • High carbohydrate intake leads to high insulin levels, promoting fat storage.
  • Lowering insulin levels is essential for accessing stored fat.

"Insulin is what tells you to store extra energy, so when your insulin levels are high, your fat storage system turns on."

  • High insulin levels signal the body to store fat.

"If your insulin levels are too high, you cannot burn fat."

  • Elevated insulin levels prevent the body from accessing stored fat for energy.

Dietary Patterns for Mental Health

  • Paleo, ketogenic, and carnivore diets are beneficial for mental health.
  • These diets make biological sense and can improve physical and emotional health.
  • Gradual transition to these diets is recommended to avoid physiological shock.

"The three dietary patterns that make the most sense to consider are paleo diets, ketogenic diets, and carnivore diets."

  • Certain diets align better with our biological needs and can enhance mental health.

"It's actually quite dangerous to adopt such a dramatic change in diet that quickly."

  • Gradual dietary changes are crucial to avoid negative health impacts.

Gradual Transition to Low-Carb Diets

  • Rapid reduction in carbohydrate intake can cause blood sugar and insulin levels to drop sharply.
  • This can lead to physiological shock and affect medication efficacy.
  • Gradual reduction is necessary to allow the body to adapt.

"You should not drop your insulin levels overnight."

  • Sudden changes in diet can have adverse effects on health.

"It's going to take days to weeks for your brain and body to find their new equilibrium and adjust to that shock."

  • The body needs time to adapt to significant dietary changes for optimal health outcomes.

Gradual Transition to Low-Carb Diets

  • Transitioning to low-carb diets should be gradual to avoid negative symptoms.
  • Rapid changes can lead to adverse effects like keto flu, lightheadedness, and difficulty concentrating.
  • Full adaptation can take from a few days to up to six months.

"Nine times out of 10 when someone consults with me to say I tried a ketogenic diet or I tried a carnivore diet or I tried a low carbohydrate diet and it made me worse, it’s because they changed their diet too quickly or only stayed on it for a few days."

  • Many people experience issues because they don't give their metabolism enough time to adapt.

"You need to start low, go slow, but you need to go all the way. You need to give yourself the time it takes for your metabolism to make that shift so that you can experience the benefits."

  • Gradual lowering of insulin and glucose levels can prevent symptoms like keto flu and exhaustion.

"Gradually lower your insulin glucose levels; that way, you won’t get a lot of the keto flu symptoms, you won’t feel lightheaded, you won’t feel like you can’t concentrate, you won’t feel exhausted."

Study on Ketogenic Diets and Mental Health

  • A 2022 study by Dr. Alber Daa involved 31 treatment-resistant patients with severe mental health disorders.
  • Participants adhered to a mildly ketogenic diet under supervision.
  • Significant improvements were observed in all participants who adhered to the diet.

"28 of those 31 patients were able to adhere to the diet for 2 weeks or longer, and all 28 of those patients improved substantially."

  • 43% achieved clinical remission from their primary psychiatric diagnosis, and 64% left the hospital on fewer psychiatric medications.

"43% of them achieved clinical remission from their primary psychiatric diagnosis, and 64% of them left the hospital with less psychiatric medication."

  • The degree of improvement was 7 to 10 times greater than typical studies of antidepressant and antipsychotic medications.

"The degree of improvement was 7 to 10 times greater than we typically see in studies of antidepressant and antipsychotic medication."

Managing Medications During Diet Transition

  • It's crucial to consult healthcare professionals before starting a lower carbohydrate diet, especially if on psychiatric medications.
  • The diet can be added to existing medications, but close supervision is needed.

"The beautiful thing about dietary strategies is it doesn’t have to be an either-or; it can be an and. You can use them together."

  • Psychiatric medications might need to be adjusted downward as the diet can duplicate their effects.

"The ketogenic diet improves the balance between GABA and glutamate. So, the medications may start to feel too strong because now you’ve got the medication and the diet trying to do the same thing."

  • Adjustments are individualized and should be done under professional supervision.

"Everyone’s taking different combinations of medications; sometimes we need to adjust them, sometimes we don’t. This is why it’s so important to work with a skilled professional."

Role of Spices and Plant Toxins

  • There is no substantial research on the impact of spices on brain health.
  • Common belief holds that spices have antioxidant and anti-inflammatory benefits, but this may not be entirely accurate.

"We’re often told the more spices, the better, right? They have these magical antioxidant anti-inflammatory capabilities."

  • Some plant compounds, like curcumin from turmeric, are poorly absorbed and can be irritants rather than beneficial.

"Curcumin is an irritant, and we absorb it very, very poorly. Researchers manipulate the curcumin to try to trick our bodies into absorbing more of it."

  • There are documented cases of severe liver toxicity and even lethal overdoses from curcumin.

"I’ve come across some cases of severe liver toxicity documented in the literature from curcumin and even lethal overdoses of curcumin."

Food as Medicine

  • The idea that food can act as medicine is challenged; food should nourish and provide energy, while medicine should be used for treatment.
  • The focus should be on removing harmful foods rather than adding supposed superfoods.

"Food is food, and medicine is medicine. Food needs to nourish, and medicine needs to treat."

  • Protecting the brain involves removing foods that cause inflammation, oxidative stress, and insulin resistance.

"Protection of the brain against inflammation and oxidative stress is not about addition; it’s about subtraction."

Encouraging Clinicians to Incorporate Nutritional Principles

  • Clinicians are encouraged to incorporate nutritional and metabolic principles into their practice.
  • Dietary strategies can complement other treatments like psychotherapy, meditation, and medications.

"Incorporating these metabolic principles is just going to augment and give your patients a much stronger foundation for whatever other types of interventions you use in your work."

  • The field of nutritional psychiatry is growing, and more research is being conducted.

"The research in the area is exploding, and I teach a CME-certified course for clinicians to learn how to safely use these dietary strategies in clinical practice."

What others are sharing

Go To Library

Want to Deciphr in private?
- It's completely free

Deciphr Now
Footer background
Crossed lines icon
Deciphr.Ai
Crossed lines icon
Deciphr.Ai
Crossed lines icon
Deciphr.Ai
Crossed lines icon
Deciphr.Ai
Crossed lines icon
Deciphr.Ai
Crossed lines icon
Deciphr.Ai
Crossed lines icon
Deciphr.Ai

© 2024 Deciphr

Terms and ConditionsPrivacy Policy