In a dynamic discussion on investment pricing strategies, top investors like Marcello Claw, Bill Gurley, Michael Eisenberg, David Tish, Cyan Bannister, Frank Rotman, Jeff Lieberman, Justin Fishner-Wolfson, Luciana Lixandru, Zach Weinberg, Jeff Lewis, Nick Shalek, and David Z weigh in on the delicate balance between price sensitivity and opportunity. They explore scenarios where paying a premium is justifiable for potentially massive markets, like those dominated by giants such as Amazon and Google, while emphasizing the importance of discipline in less expansive markets. The conversation also touches on the evolving venture landscape, where traditional ownership models are contested against the backdrop of high growth potential and the necessity to adapt to founders' market conditions. They collectively underscore the significance of quality asset selection, the potential for long-term value creation, and the need for investors to remain agile, often bending their own rules to seize exceptional opportunities.
"The key is to determine in advance if it's a company where price matters or it doesn't."
This quote emphasizes the strategic importance of identifying whether the price is a critical factor before investing in a company.
"For some companies with an immense opportunity, think of Alibaba, think of Facebook, think of Google, think of Amazon. Whatever it was worth coming in at almost any price because the market was so large."
The quote suggests that for companies with massive market opportunities, the entry price is less important because the potential returns are so high.
"Now, other companies, we've done incredibly well because we've learned to make that distinction where price matters and where it doesn't."
This reflects on the learning curve and the importance of discerning when to focus on price and when to prioritize market potential in investment decisions.
"The problem is it's a highly distributed field of players. There are thousands and thousands of VCs and way more of that of entrepreneurs, and we don't get to decide. The market does that via supply and demand."
This quote explains the decentralized nature of the venture capital market and the role of supply and demand in determining investment dynamics.
"I think you have to invest as a venture capitalist over the cycle, like over a 20 or 30 year period."
Bill Gurley suggests a long-term investment approach to navigate through the various market cycles effectively.
"There were several firms in Silicon Valley that in the 96 time frame said, this is all crazy. This is too expensive. And they pulled out and they missed the best three years in a 20 year window of return."
This historical example serves as a cautionary tale about the risks of pulling out of the market due to high prices and potentially missing out on significant returns.
"Bill mentioned the early stage point, the thing at Olive that guides us, which one of the things I learned at benchmark is that ownership still matters a lot."
This quote by Harry Stebbings underscores the importance of ownership in early-stage investments and how it guides investment decisions.
"The second way I think about is if I need to be the highest priced bidder on the company, on the founder of the CEO, I'm doing something wrong."
Harry Stebbings expresses that if an investor needs to rely solely on offering the highest price, they may be lacking in other areas of value proposition.
"I still deeply believe that relationships matter more than anything in this business, and networks matter more than anything in order to accelerate those entrepreneurs."
This quote emphasizes the importance Harry Stebbings places on relationships and networks in the venture capital industry, highlighting their role in supporting and accelerating entrepreneurs.
"I prefer to optimize long term on reputation rather than optimizing on dollars."
Harry Stebbings expresses a preference for building a long-term reputation over short-term financial gains, suggesting that a strong reputation can be more valuable than immediate monetary optimization.
"It is important to be price aware on a portfolio basis, and I don't think on a deal by deal basis, price is a determinant of making a decision."
Bill Gurley discusses the importance of being aware of pricing from a portfolio perspective rather than focusing solely on the cost of individual deals.
"If I look at a fund and I say our entry point is up three x from our last fund, that's a problem."
Bill Gurley points out that a significant increase in the entry point for a fund compared to previous funds may indicate an issue, suggesting a need for understanding portfolio pricing.
"What's going to happen is there's going to be a reckoning, and there always is."
Speaker C predicts a future market correction where returns will be scrutinized, leading to increased discipline in the venture capital market.
"To be able to get those kind of returns, you've got to be more price sensitive."
Speaker C underscores the importance of price sensitivity in achieving high returns, suggesting that a lack of sensitivity can negatively impact investment success.
"Outcomes are bigger than anyone expected them to be and should factor into what a company is ultimately worth."
Frank Rotman discusses how the potential outcomes for venture-backed companies have grown, affecting their valuation and the consideration of their worth.
"It's about comfortable being uncomfortable. It's about conviction. It's about knowing when to bend your own rules."
Frank Rotman talks about the challenges of investment decision-making in a rapidly changing environment and the need for flexibility and conviction.
"Higher price for a lot of the companies that we ended up paying up for. So far so good."
Frank Rotman reflects on the outcomes of paying higher prices for certain investments, indicating that so far, the companies they've invested in have performed well.
"They were the companies that had massive momentum on their side."
Frank Rotman justifies paying a higher price for companies with significant momentum, suggesting that this momentum can be a critical factor in the company's future success.
"So we spend a lot more thinking about the quality of an asset and the future potentiality of the asset."
This quote explains that Gurley and his team prioritize understanding the intrinsic quality and future growth potential of an investment, rather than just the current financial metrics.
"One SaaS company will have a 50% cash flow margin, the other will have a 20% cash flow margin."
Here, Gurley is explaining the disparity in profitability between different companies within the same industry, which can significantly impact their long-term value.
"I think in times like this, we typically average assets get priced way up, great assets get priced up, but the spread between those assets probably compresses."
This quote indicates that during certain market conditions, the difference in valuation between average and great assets narrows, affecting investment strategies.
"So I think there's even more opportunity within that to figure out which ones we believe will be the winners and have sustainable advantage and ultimately sustainable economics."
Gurley points out that the real opportunity lies in identifying companies that will maintain a competitive edge and sustainable financial performance over time.
"So it only matters when things go well. And so then the question is, can you invest at prices that ultimately hit your cost of capital?"
This quote underlines the idea that investment pricing is critical when the company succeeds and must align with the investor's cost of capital to justify the investment.
"I think a lot of this has to do with heuristics that were created a long time ago."
Fishner-Wolfson is suggesting that the industry's focus on ownership percentages is based on historical heuristics that may not always apply in the current investment landscape.
"With growth, I do think it's different. With growth, I really think you need to stay sober."
Luciana contrasts the approach to early-stage investing with growth-stage investing, where pricing becomes more important due to the reduced potential for upside.
"I think selecting the right company in the early stages is all that matters."
This quote emphasizes Luciana's belief that in early-stage investments, the primary focus should be on choosing the right company, as it is paramount for long-term success.
"We're looking for things where the multiple on the next round, not because I care about the markup at all, but because it shows real growth and real value creation, is more than like two x."
Weinberg explains that he looks for investments where the next round's valuation multiple reflects genuine growth and value creation, rather than just an increase in paper value.
"Your winners have to win big, and they have to pay for all the losers, because there's quite a few."
This quote emphasizes the necessity for significant wins in venture capital to cover the inevitable losses from other investments.
"Getting that pricing right is actually really important."
The importance of accurate pricing is highlighted, especially when increasing investment in a company one is already familiar with.
"Less price sensitivity, I think, is okay."
This quote suggests a more flexible approach to price sensitivity when making an initial investment in a company.
"You have to have extremely high conviction and to have done your diligence and really believe this set of entrepreneurs, this company is going to transcend."
The need for strong belief in a company's potential and team is highlighted as a justification for investing at high valuations.
"The only way to earn exceptional returns, if you want to generate several multiples of whatever LPs trust you with, the only way to do that is to be contrarian, since otherwise returns get competed away."
This quote underscores the necessity of having a unique investment perspective to achieve outstanding returns.
"One of the hardest things I found in tech investing is updating your priors."
The challenge of reassessing and expanding one's view of a company's potential worth is discussed, emphasizing the importance of adaptability in investment strategies.
"Does this show the potential to be a winner takes most or winner takes all kind of business?"
This question reflects the importance of identifying companies with the potential to dominate their market, which can inform investment decisions despite high valuations.
"You can invest at different points along the stack than we used to think and have great returns."
The evolving landscape of investment opportunities across different stages is acknowledged, suggesting a more dynamic approach to venture capital.
"More than 70% of companies who start using notion stop using two plus other tools."
The efficiency and effectiveness of Notion as a multi-purpose tool for businesses is highlighted, suggesting its value in streamlining operations.
"Whether you're running SPVs, a traditional venture fund like me, or a rolling fund, AngelList has you covered."
AngelList is promoted as a versatile platform suitable for various types of investment management, emphasizing its utility for investors.
"Squarespace is the all in one platform to build a beautiful online presence and run your business."
The all-encompassing features of Squarespace for business management and online presence are touted, including its ease of use and effective SEO tools.